Pages

Thursday, February 3, 2011

If Sibal was right, then why Raja's arrest?


Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) leader Sitaram Yechury Wednesday said that if the new communication minister, Kapil Sibal, was right when he said there was no problem in the allocation of 2G spectrum, then why did the CBI arrest his predecessor A. Raja.
"If Sibal was right, then why the arrest," Yechury told a TV channel after reports of the CBI arresting Raja and two of his aides were flashed across the media.
"It only vindicates our position that there is very very deep malaise behind the scam," he said.
The CPI-M leader said that the issue was not only about the investigation which is being conducted by the CBI under the supervision of the Supreme Court.
"The bigger issue is how was the system allowed to be manipulated in such a huge way," he said, adding that the party's demand for a joint parliamentary committee probe into the matter was vindicated.

2G scam: How it all happened


Following is a primer on the second-generation spectrum allocation scandal that resulted in former communications minister A. Raja of DMK being arrested here Tuesday:
The issue dates to 2008 when nine telecom companies were issued scarce airwaves, a national resource, and licences for 2G mobile phone services at Rs.1,658 crore (less that $350 million) for a pan-India operation. As many as 122 circle-wise licences were issued.
The opposition said by giving airwaves cheap and in a controversial manner of first-cum-first-served basis, the exchequer had lost billions of dollars. It also objected to the arbitrary advancement of the cut-off date for filing applications to suit some firms.
But Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself defended Raja's decision and said May 24 last year that his communications minister had done no wrong and had only implemented the policy that was already in place. No norm wasn flouted, he added.
The opposition nevertheless stepped up its attack with two examples on 2G spectrumsale:
- A new player, Swan Telecom, bought licences for 13 circles with the necessary spectrum for $340 million but managed to sell a 45-percent stake in the company to UAE's Etisalat for $900 million. This swelled its valuation to $2 billion without a single subscriber.
- Another new player, Unitech, paid $365 million as licence fee but sold a 60-percent stake to Norway's Talenor for $1.36 billion, taking its valuation to nearly $2 billion, again without a single subscriber.
Similarly, another licensor, Datacom, later became Videocon Mobile and Stel now has large stake by Bahrain Telecom. The other companies are Tata Tele, Idea Cellular, Loop Telecom, Shyam Telelink and Spice.
The isue cropped up again after auction of airwaves for third-generation (3G) services that fetched nearly $15 billion and for broadband access, which fetched over $8.5 billion to the exchequer. Accordingly the the notional loss on 2G was estimated at $12.8 billion to $38 billion.
This estimate was arrived at by the Compteoller and Auditor General of India and leaked to some sections of the media, forcing Raja to regisn Nov 5 from the union council of ministers holding the communications and IT portfolio.
The official auditor also said the entire process of spectrum allocation was undertaken in an extremely arbitrary manner and that the advise of industry watchdog, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), was ignored and misused.
Meanwhile, Janata Party leader Subramanian Swamy filed a suit in the Supreme Court seeking judicial intervention in giving directions to the government and probe agencies to act against Raja.
Acting on the petition, the Supreme Court had asked the solicitor general last October why Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had not responded in a timely manner to a request by Swamy to sanction proceedings against Raja.
Then in December, the apex court itself decided to monitor the probe, that was being conducted by multiple agencies, including the CBI and the Enforcement Directorate. The agencies have to submit their respective reports to the apex court by Feb 10.

What to do with arrested Raja?


Moments after the news about the arrest of former Telecommunications Minister A. Raja came in, the social networking world started discussing, debating the aftermath.
On Twitter a few users raised the question on the jail. One such tweet says, 'So willRaja be sent to Kala Pani? It used to be called Cellular Jail, you know.' Quiet a handful of twitterers are guessing that the political power behind Raja would get him out in bail, in a few days and if that takes a time then a fake illness case would keep him out of the prison.

A senior journalist (@BDUTT), who was initially alleged for witnessing and to some extent influencing the appointment of Raja as telecom minister too commented, “Finally, Raja and two former aides are arrested. Clear damage control ahead of next Parliament session. Unlikely to end opposition attacks.”
Some of the widely circulated tweets are:
  • It was my husband's dream that one day a Dalit name will be on every news paper front page.. every TV channel. Proud of A Raja
  • Yeddy sacrificed a donkey to ward off evil. UPA sacrificed a bakra to ward off JPC & for TN elections. #Raja arrested
  • Mubarak sues Raja for lifting his speech. He allegedly said "This is a political conspiracy to defame me & my party. I'm innocent!"
  • A Raja found doing suryanamaskar in his balcony wearing telephone wires.
  • A Raja could have easily avoided this arrest if he had performed suryanamaskars in the buff last week.
  • As a coincidence, today is Amavasya.. Karunanidhi decided to give A Raja as a sacrificial goat to Sonia Gandhi for his own dear family..
What happened after the arrest, how Raja would be punished.. many such questions would be answered with time, but going by the verdict of the tweeple, the punishment should be big enough to bring an end to corruption.

SC pulls up govt in Amar Singh phone-tap case


The Supreme Court Wednesday pulled up the government, Delhi Police, a telecom operator and Rajya Sabha member Amar Singh for filing "very casual and vague" affidavits and asked them to file these afresh in the former Samajwadi Party leader's phone tapping case.
The apex court bench of Justice G.S. Singhvi and Justice A.K. Ganguly said casual and vague affidavits have been filed by all on such a serious issue.
"It is a very serious issue and all the affidavits have been filed in a very casual manner," the court said.
The court asked Solicitor General Gopal Subramanium to file a status report on a case in trial court relating to criminal conspiracy in tapping Amar Singh's phone.
Appearing for petitioner Amar Singh, senior counsel Harish Salve said that though Delhi Police have washed their hands of the case by claiming that the letter that formed the basis for tapping Singh's phone was forged, his right to privacy had been breached. This could not be overlooked, Salve said.
He said that the central government was under constitutional mandate to protect his client's right to privacy. He said telecom operators were working under its (central government's) licence.
"A service provider who was working under the statutory authority was bound by the statute. There was a cosy relationship between the government and the service provider," Salve told the court.
The court chided counsel for the telecom operator for not furnishing the full record. The court said that as per the affidavit, "there is a record. Show us the record".
Justice Ganguly asked: "Which agency has requested (you) to tap the phone?"
Justice Ganguly asked how the service provider could tap a phone on the request of police whereas procedurally it was done on the sanction by union home secretary. Justice Ganguly said the "affidavit of the service provider was very vague".
When Salve said, "What happens to my right? I have been defamed", the court told him to go to the criminal court.
The court said: "The question is who defamed you. The government is (ruled) out, after denying its involvement in the matter."
The case relates to Amar Singh's phone tapping, which created a furore in political circle. Singh alleged that he was the target of political vendetta.
The apex court took up the hearing in the case, which was stayed in 2006, following an application by the Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) for vacation of the stay and permitting Amar Singh tapes to be brought into in public domain.
Senior counsel Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the CPIL, said that everything in the tapes that concerns the dirty tricks to influence the governance in the country should be made public.
He said it was people's right to know the manner in which they were being governed.
The matter will come up for hearing Feb 9. 

India's s/w exports seen up 16-18 p.c. in FY12


India's software and services exports are seen rising 16-18 per cent in the year to March 2012, an industry body said on Wednesday, as demand foroutsourcing services by Western clients is expected to remain strong.
The National Association of Software & Services Cos (NASSCOM) forecast export revenue of $68 billion to $70 billion for India's showpiece outsourcing sector in fiscal 2012.
India's IT sector, whose clients include General Electric and Citigroup, would see export revenue rise 18.7 per cent to $59 billion in fiscal 2011, NASSCOM said.
It had estimated export revenue of $56-$57 billion last February.
"Pent-up demand for IT-BPO services, return of discretionary spending, new business models that encouraged first time buyers, and re-invented value proposition for existing ones, were the key drivers for the industry performance," Som Mittal, president of NASSCOM said in a statement.
Last month, India's top two software services exporters Tata Consultancy Services and Infosys Technologies said business remains good in 2011 but were worried Europe's debt crisis and rising domestic inflation could weigh on growth.
India's share in the global outsourcing market rose to 55 per cent in 2010 from 51 in 2009, NASSCOM added, as demand from the U.S. market and banking and financial services industry grew.

Kerala finally clears Smart City project


The deadlock between the Kerala government andSmart City Dubai over the proposed Rs.1,500 crore Smart City Kochi project finally ended on Wednesday following talks between Chief Minister V.S. Achuthanandan and United Arab Emirates (UAE) government representative Ahmed Humaid Al Tayer.
Speaking to reporters after the weekly cabinet meeting here, Achuthanandan said the project is now through and will go into the implementing phase.
"The lease agreement will be ready in a week for the transfer of the land and the government has decided to exempt the land transfer deal from stamp duty and registration fees. And soon the master plan would be ready and the work also will start," said Achuthanandan.
Reacting to the opposition's allegations that it has been delayed for many years and a huge loss has been caused to the state exchequer, the chief minister shot back, "several times they had gone to the project site and laid wreaths and now that this has become a reality, they have to say some excuses."
Earlier Wednesday, Achuthanandan held talks with the Dubai government team here.
"The project is going to be a reality and the details will be announced soon after the cabinet meeting," said Achuthanandan.
A nine-point agreement to this effect was signed by the two parties.
It was more than three years back that the foundation stone for the project was laid and since then, work has been held up over the issue of granting 12 percent freehold rights to the builders outside of the 246 acres of the proposed project site.
Sources close to the government say the issue was settled after the government agreed to give 12 percent freehold rights, but within the 246 acres which would come under the special economic zone and cannot be sold.
The talks had broken down last year and Achuthanandan had more than once blamed Smart City Dubai, saying it was intentionally delaying the project as it was broke. He had even described Smart City Kochi's chief executive officer Fareed Abdulrahman "a drunk."
But the turnaround came after the state government appointed UAE-based businessman from Kerala, M.A.Yousuf Ali, to negotiate with the UAE government.
"I had eight rounds of talks with the UAE officials and several informal talks with them. It has now become a reality and I am happy that thousands of youths in the state will get jobs once the Smart City Kochi becomes a reality," said Ali, who attended the meeting.
Speaking to reporters, local Congress legislator K. Babu said that even though he was happy that the differences have been resolved, some questions still remained unanswered.
"The larger question is why this nearly four-year-long delay and who is to be blamed for this? Had the state government been more sincere and had it gone ahead in the same speed after the foundation stone was laid, then by now people would have been working there," said Babu.

Arrest doesn't make Raja guilty: DMK


 Tamil Nadu's ruling DMK Thursday came out in support of its former communications minister A. Raja and said his arrest in the 2G spectrum allocation scam did not make him guilty.
The party's all-powerful General Council met here and passed a resolution condemning the opposition for blowing the spectrum scam out of proportion. It said the arrest of a person does not necessarily make him guilty.
Raja, also the DMK's propaganda secretary, and two of his aides were arrested by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in New Delhi Wednesday for their role in the controversial allocation of airwaves for second generation (2G) telecom services.
Raja was forced to resign Nov 14 last year after the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) indicted him in the scam and for causing losses between Rs.58,000 crore ($12.8 billion) and Rs.1.76 lakh crore ($40 billion) to the exchequer.
The DMK, a key ally of the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) at the centre, Wednesday maintained a studied silence on the arrest with no leaders willing to comment on the matter.
Karunanidhi had earlier said action would be taken against Raja if he was proven guilty.
The General Council also passed a resolution calling for a new agreement with Sri Lanka giving rights to Indian fishermen to fish near Katchatheevu - the islet that was given to the island nation in the 1970s.